Section 406 CrPC (Section 446 BNSS): Transfer of Criminal Cases by the Supreme Court
Section 406 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) corresponds to Section 446 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), in force from 1 July 2024. A transfer petition pending on that date continues under the CrPC (see our article on Section 531 BNSS); a fresh petition is ordinarily filed under the BNSS. The Supreme Court’s reasoning under Section 406 remains the working guide for both.
Section 406 CrPC empowers the Supreme Court of India to transfer a criminal case or appeal from one High Court to another, or from a criminal court subordinate to one High Court to a court of equal or superior jurisdiction subordinate to another High Court, whenever this is “expedient for the ends of justice”. In practice, it is the remedy for a litigant who cannot expect a fair trial in the State where the case is pending, or for whom continuing there would be a serious injustice. The bar is high: the Supreme Court treats transfer as an exceptional step and insists on a reasonable apprehension, not a bare allegation.
1. What Section 406 provides
We summarise the provision in our own words. Please read the statutory text before quoting it.
- Sub-section (1): the power. Where it appears to the Supreme Court that an order under the section is expedient for the ends of justice, it may direct that a particular case or appeal be transferred (a) from one High Court to another High Court, or (b) from a criminal court subordinate to one High Court to a criminal court of equal or superior jurisdiction subordinate to another High Court.
- Sub-section (2): who can apply and how. The Court acts only on the application of the Attorney General of India or of a party interested. The application is made by motion and, except where the applicant is the Attorney General or the Advocate General of a State, must be supported by an affidavit or affirmation.
- Sub-section (3): costs for frivolous petitions. If the application is dismissed and the Court considers it frivolous or vexatious, it may order the applicant to pay compensation to the person who opposed it, up to a capped sum. The CrPC cap was a modest figure; check whether and how the BNSS version (Section 446) changes the amount.
Constitutional companions. Article 139A of the Constitution gives the Supreme Court a separate power to transfer cases between High Courts where cases involving the same or substantially similar questions of law are pending, and Article 142 supports complete justice in a given case. Section 406 is the criminal procedure route that most petitioners invoke.
2. Where Section 406 sits among the transfer provisions
Criminal procedure provides a ladder of transfer powers, and the first step in advising a client is to pick the right rung.
| Provision (CrPC / BNSS) | Who decides | What can be transferred |
| Section 406 / Section 446 | Supreme Court | Cases and appeals between High Courts (inter-state or across High Court jurisdictions) |
| Section 407 / Section 447 | High Court | Cases from one subordinate court to another within the same State, or to the High Court itself |
| Section 408 / Section 448 | Sessions Judge | Cases from one criminal court to another within the sessions division |
| Section 409 / Section 449 | Sessions Judge | Withdrawal of cases or appeals by the Sessions Judge |
| Section 410 / Section 450 | Chief Judicial Magistrate | Withdrawal and re-assignment among Magistrates |
Takeaway: if both the court where the case is pending and the court you want it moved to are in the same State, go to the High Court under Section 407 (Section 447 BNSS). Section 406 is for the case that must cross a High Court’s boundary.
3. The governing test: fair trial, not convenience alone
The leading decisions have settled the principles over decades.
- Gurcharan Dass Chadha v. State of Rajasthan (AIR 1966 SC 1418): the Court examined the idea of a reasonable apprehension that a fair and impartial trial will not be held, and stressed that the apprehension must rest on facts.
- Maneka Sanjay Gandhi v. Rani Jethmalani (1979) 4 SCC 167: the Court said that the central question is whether the petitioner has a reasonable apprehension that justice will not be done. The Court cautioned against treating a mere assertion of inconvenience or an unsubstantiated fear as enough, and observed that a fair and impartial atmosphere for trial is the aim.
- Abdul Nazar Madani v. State of Tamil Nadu (2000) 6 SCC 204: the Court emphasised that the apprehension must be reasonable and not imaginary or based on conjecture, and that the court is not to be swayed by the petitioner’s subjective feeling.
- Nahar Singh Yadav v. Union of India (2011) 1 SCC 307: the Court reviewed the earlier authorities and restated the circumstances in which transfer may be ordered. These include situations in which the State machinery or prosecution is acting in concert with the other side, the comparative hardship to the accused, the complainant and witnesses, and a communal or otherwise hostile atmosphere that makes a fair trial doubtful.
Taken together, the position is this: fairness of trial is the touchstone. Convenience of parties, distance, expense and inconvenience to witnesses are relevant, but on their own they rarely carry a petition, except in categories such as matrimonial disputes where courts have been sensitive to the situation of a woman petitioner with small children.
4. Decisions that show the power in action
These cases illustrate how the Court has applied the test to very different facts. Read each one in full before relying on it.
- Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat (2004) 4 SCC 158 (Best Bakery case): the Court expressed grave concern over the fairness of the trial and ordered retrial outside the State, stressing that a trial must be fair to the victim and the accused alike and that the public prosecutor and the court have duties in securing that.
- Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India (the Bilkis Bano matter): a case transferred out of Gujarat to Maharashtra because of threats and concerns about the integrity of the process.
- Jayendra Saraswathi Swamigal v. State of Tamil Nadu (2005) 8 SCC 771: trial transferred out of the State on the Court’s finding that the circumstances justified it, the Court also noting that conduct of the State machinery bore on the question.
- Captain Amarinder Singh v. Parkash Singh Badal (2009) 6 SCC 260: the Court considered the grounds of apprehension against a trial in the State and addressed the standard for establishing them.
- Rajesh Talwar v. CBI (2012) 4 SCC 217: an example in which the Court examined whether the circumstances of a high-profile trial warranted transfer from one place to another.
Using these cases: a good petition does not just list authorities. It maps its own facts onto one of these patterns and shows documentary support.
5. Grounds on which petitions are commonly made
- Hostile atmosphere or threat to the accused, complainant or witnesses. Strongest when supported by police reports, FIRs for threats, or other documentary material.
- Prosecution or State machinery apparently acting in concert with the opposite side. Requires concrete conduct, such as demonstrable partisan acts, not a general allegation of political rivalry.
- Reasonable apprehension of bias in the court or the presiding officer. Courts are careful here. Allegations against a judicial officer must be framed responsibly and with particulars.
- Multiplicity of proceedings arising from the same transaction in different States. Transfer is sought to consolidate and avoid conflicting outcomes and multiple trials on the same facts.
- Hardship in attending a distant court. Considered alongside other factors; seldom enough alone, but more persuasive for a woman petitioner in a matrimonial or domestic violence dispute, a person with serious illness, or an accused who is a minor’s sole caregiver.
- Security risk to the accused in custody or in transit.
- Common questions in connected cases where a single forum would serve the ends of justice.
6. Who can file, and how
- Who: the Attorney General of India or any party interested, such as the accused, the complainant or the State. Persons with no interest in the case cannot file.
- Form: a transfer petition (criminal) filed in the Supreme Court as a motion, supported by an affidavit (unless the applicant is the Attorney General or an Advocate General).
- Rules: the filing, defects, notice and listing requirements are in the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 under the provisions for transfer petitions. Check the current Order and the Registry’s checklist before filing.
- Contents of a sound petition:
- Parties and case details (court, case number, stage, sections charged)
- A chronology of the case and of the events that give rise to the apprehension
- The specific grounds, each paired with annexed material
- Previous applications and orders, including any proceedings in the High Court
- The court to which transfer is sought, with reasons why that court is suitable
- Prayer for transfer, with an alternative prayer for directions to protect the trial (such as video-conferencing or special security)
- Prayer for interim stay of proceedings, if justified
- Notice: the Supreme Court usually issues notice to the respondents and the State(s) concerned, and calls for the record where necessary.
7. Interim stay and the progress of the trial
Petitioners often ask for a stay of the trial pending the transfer petition. The Court does not grant it as a matter of course. It will ask whether the trial is at a stage where a stay would cause prejudice, whether the petition is serious, and whether there is any delay in approaching the Court. A petition filed on the eve of verdict or after prolonged participation in the trial invites scepticism.
8. Common reasons petitions fail
- Bare allegations of bias or hostility without material.
- Forum preference dressed as apprehension. The Court distinguishes between a genuine fear of an unfair trial and a wish for a more comfortable venue.
- Delay in approaching the Court after the alleged grounds arose.
- Suppression of earlier proceedings, such as a prior unsuccessful application under Section 407 CrPC or a refusal of a request for transfer within the State.
- Attacks on the judiciary in language that is disproportionate. This risks adverse comment and costs under sub-section (3).
- Seeking transfer to avoid the consequences of the trial, for example when the accused has been avoiding appearance.
9. Section 406 and the BNSS transition
- A petition pending before the Supreme Court on 1 July 2024 continues under the CrPC under the savings clause (Section 531(2)(a) BNSS), on the plain reading of the provision.
- A fresh petition after that date is ordinarily filed under Section 446 BNSS, even where the underlying case began under the CrPC. Courts have not treated the choice of statute as changing the substance of the transfer test.
- Where there is doubt, cite both provisions in the alternative.
- The core precedents under Section 406 are expected to continue to guide the Court under Section 446, as the language of the two provisions is substantially the same, subject to the changes noted above (including the costs provision).
10. Frequently asked questions
Can I go to the Supreme Court directly for a transfer within my own State?
The ordinary route for transfer within a State is the High Court under Section 407 CrPC (Section 447 BNSS). Section 406 is for transfers across High Court jurisdictions.
Is a transfer petition an appeal against the trial court’s order?
No. It is an original application to the Supreme Court. It does not challenge the merits of any order.
Can the complainant, and not just the accused, seek transfer?
Yes. Any party interested may apply, and the Court has transferred cases on the application of victims and complainants.
Will the Court transfer a case simply because the parties live in different States?
Not by itself. Convenience is a factor, and in some categories (particularly matrimonial matters involving a woman petitioner) it carries more weight, but the Court looks for a real concern about the fairness or practicability of the trial.
What happens to the evidence already recorded?
That depends on the order. The Court may direct that the trial continue from the stage reached, or that proceedings start afresh. The order will say, and it is worth asking for clarity in the prayer.
Can I be penalised for filing?
If the petition is dismissed and found frivolous or vexatious, the Court may order compensation to the opposing party under sub-section (3), up to the stated cap.
11. Checklist before you file
- Confirmed that the transfer is across High Court jurisdictions (otherwise Section 407 / 447)
- Identified the specific, evidence-backed grounds for the apprehension
- Annexed FIRs, complaints, police communications or other material supporting each ground
- Disclosed all prior proceedings and applications
- Named the transferee court and explained why it is suitable
- Considered whether interim relief is justified, and framed the prayer accordingly
- Prepared the affidavit (unless the applicant is the Attorney General or an Advocate General)
- Cited both CrPC and BNSS provisions where the position is uncertain
- Verified every case citation and the current Supreme Court Rules
Section 406 CrPC, now Section 446 BNSS, is a safety valve for the fairness of the criminal process. It is narrow by design: the Supreme Court looks for a genuine and evidenced fear that justice cannot be done in the existing forum, and is slow to treat convenience or tactics as a substitute. A well-prepared petition therefore does three things: it grounds each apprehension in documents, it shows candour about the case history, and it explains why the proposed forum will secure a fair trial.
By entering the email address you agree to our Privacy Policy.
