Section 531 BNSS: Repeal and Savings Explained, and Which Law Governs Your Pending Criminal Case
Section 531 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) repeals the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) and contains the savings clause that decides what happens to proceedings already under way on 1 July 2024, when the BNSS came into force. In broad terms: an appeal, application, trial, inquiry or investigation that was pending immediately before 1 July 2024 continues under the CrPC “as if the BNSS had not come into force”. Everything else is governed by the BNSS.
The difficulty is not the rule. It is the word “pending”. A case does not move through a single event; it moves through an FIR, an investigation, a chargesheet, cognizance, committal, charge, trial and appeal. Which of these must have begun before 1 July 2024 for the CrPC to survive is the question on which courts and litigants have spent two years.
1. What Section 531 says
Section 531 has two moving parts. We summarise them here in our words, and you should read the statutory text itself before citing it.
- Sub-section (1) repeals the CrPC.
- Sub-section (2) says that, despite the repeal:
- Clause (a): if immediately before the BNSS came into force there was any appeal, application, trial, inquiry or investigation pending, it is to be disposed of, continued, held or made in accordance with the CrPC as it stood, as if the BNSS had not been enacted.
- Clause (b): notifications, proclamations, powers conferred, forms, local jurisdictions, sentences, orders, rules and appointments made under the CrPC and in force immediately before commencement, if not inconsistent with the BNSS, are deemed to have been made under the corresponding BNSS provisions.
The Section also contains further provisions on references to the repealed Code and related matters. Check the full text.
Companion provision for substantive law: the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) has its own repeal-and-savings clause, Section 358. For offences committed before 1 July 2024, the IPC continues to govern the definition and punishment of the offence, because of Article 20(1) of the Constitution, which bars conviction or a greater penalty under a law not in force when the act was done. So a single case can be tried under IPC for the offence and BNSS for some procedure, depending on the stage.
2. Why “procedure” and “substance” behave differently
Indian law has long distinguished the two:
- Substantive law (what is an offence, what is the punishment) cannot be applied retrospectively to the accused’s disadvantage. Article 20(1) is the constitutional anchor.
- Procedural law is generally presumed to apply to pending proceedings unless the legislature says otherwise. The Supreme Court’s reasoning in cases such as Rattan Lal v. State of Punjab (AIR 1965 SC 444) reflects this: no one has a vested right in a particular form of procedure.
- Exception: a vested right of appeal is treated as substantive and is preserved. See Garikapati Veeraya v. N. Subbiah Choudhry (AIR 1957 SC 540).
Section 531(2)(a) is the legislature saying otherwise in express words. It overrides the default presumption, preserving the CrPC for matters already pending. That is why the case law now turns on the meaning of the words in the savings clause, rather than on the general retrospectivity rule.
3. The core question: when is something “pending”?
The clause lists five things: appeal, application, trial, inquiry and investigation. Each has its own answer, and the same case can have all five at different moments.
| Stage | Likely governing procedure if the stage began before 1 July 2024 | Likely governing procedure if the stage began on or after 1 July 2024 |
| Investigation | CrPC (investigation pending on commencement) | BNSS |
| Inquiry / trial | CrPC | BNSS (but see the “mixed case” problem below) |
| Appeal | CrPC, and a vested right of appeal is preserved | BNSS |
| Application (bail, discharge, quashing and so on) | CrPC if the application was pending on commencement | BNSS, and this is the position commonly followed in practice |
This table states the general reading. The contested territory is the mixed case, discussed next.
4. The mixed case: FIR before 1 July 2024, later steps after it
This is the scenario practitioners meet most. An FIR was registered in, say, March 2024. The investigation was still on when the BNSS commenced. The chargesheet was filed in September 2024. Cognizance was taken in October 2024. Which procedure governs which stage?
There are broadly three approaches that arguments and judgments have taken. We describe them as approaches, not as a settled ranking:
- The “investigation pending” approach. Because the investigation was pending on 1 July 2024, the clause says it must be continued under the CrPC. Courts adopting this reasoning treat the entire investigation, and in some versions the consequential proceedings that flow from it, as CrPC matters.
- The “stage-by-stage” approach. Each stage is looked at separately. Investigation continues under the CrPC, but once a chargesheet is filed after 1 July 2024 and cognizance is taken, the trial is a fresh proceeding commencing under the BNSS.
- The “whole proceeding” approach. The FIR is the starting point. All steps that follow from an FIR lodged before the commencement date are governed by the CrPC, including trial.
High Courts have not spoken with one voice on where to draw the line, and the Supreme Court may yet give the controlling answer. Before relying on any proposition, check the most recent decision of your own High Court and any Supreme Court ruling on this point.
Why it matters in practice
The answer decides things that can change the outcome of a case:
- Discharge timelines. The BNSS adds a sixty-day window to apply for discharge (Sections 250 and 262 BNSS). Under the CrPC, there is no such stated period. If your case is a CrPC case, a limitation objection should fail; if it is a BNSS case, you must file in time.
- Police custody. BNSS Section 187 changes how the fifteen-day police custody period may be distributed across the detention period. The CrPC position (Section 167) differs.
- Default bail. The periods and the timing of the right under Section 167(2) CrPC and Section 187(3) BNSS should be read side by side for the case at hand.
- Charge framing and trial timelines. BNSS prescribes time limits at several stages that the CrPC does not.
- Electronic processes. BNSS provisions on electronic summons, electronic evidence and audio-video recording of search and seizure apply only if the BNSS governs.
- Mandatory forensic visit for serious offences under the BNSS, and the way evidence is later assessed.
- Attachment and forfeiture of proceeds of crime under the BNSS, which has no direct CrPC equivalent.
5. Applications filed after 1 July 2024 in older cases
A common situation: the FIR is old, but the accused files a fresh bail application after 1 July 2024. Is that application “pending” on commencement? No, because it did not exist. Read literally, clause (a) does not save it, and the BNSS applies. In practice, this is how bail applications have widely been dealt with (Section 480 BNSS for regular bail from a Magistrate, Section 483 BNSS for the Sessions Court and High Court, and Section 482 BNSS for anticipatory bail), although the substantive tests are largely carried over from the CrPC.
By contrast, an application that was already pending before 1 July 2024 should continue under the CrPC.
Practical drafting tip: Where the governing statute is open to doubt, plead the relevant provision of both the CrPC and the BNSS in the alternative. A court will rarely penalise you for a belt-and-braces citation, but it may refuse an application that cites a provision that does not apply.
6. Transition issues by common proceeding
6.1 Bail and anticipatory bail
The BNSS version of anticipatory bail (Section 482) closely follows Section 438 CrPC. Regular bail provisions (Sections 478 to 483) correspond to Sections 436 to 439 CrPC, with the addition of a provision for first-time offenders who have served one-third of the maximum sentence. For an old case, the question of which provision applies still depends on the date the application was made, as above.
6.2 Quashing and inherent powers
The High Court’s inherent power under Section 482 CrPC is now in Section 528 BNSS. A petition pending on 1 July 2024 continues under the CrPC; a fresh petition after that date is typically filed under Section 528 BNSS, with the long line of CrPC precedents (such as the Bhajan Lal categories) continuing to guide the court. The substance has not changed, and courts have generally treated the earlier case law as applicable.
6.3 Revision and appeals
Revision, which was Section 397 CrPC and is now Section 438 BNSS, and appeals follow the same logic. A vested right of appeal that arose from an order or judgment before the commencement date remains governed by the CrPC.
6.4 Discharge and framing of charge
If cognizance and committal happened before 1 July 2024, a discharge application should be argued under Sections 227, 239 or 245 CrPC. If the committal or supply of documents occurred after that date and the court treats the BNSS as applicable, Sections 250, 262 or 268 BNSS and their time limits come into play. Counsel should record in the application which statute they invoke and why.
7. How to analyse your own case: a five-step method
- Build a dated timeline of the FIR, investigation steps, arrest, chargesheet, cognizance, committal, charge and any pending applications.
- Identify the proceeding you are about to file or oppose (bail, discharge, quashing, appeal).
- Ask whether that specific proceeding, or the stage it belongs to, was pending on 1 July 2024. If yes, the CrPC applies on the clause’s wording. If no, ask whether a court has treated the broader proceeding as a CrPC matter.
- Check the latest judgments of your High Court and the Supreme Court on the precise point, such as whether the date of FIR, the date of cognizance or the date of the application controls.
- Plead in the alternative where the answer is not settled, and record your reasoning in the first paragraph of the application.
8. Common mistakes
- Assuming the date of the offence decides the procedural law. It decides the substantive law (IPC or BNS). Procedure follows a different logic.
- Assuming the date of the FIR is always decisive. It is the strongest argument for a CrPC case, but it is not the only view courts have taken.
- Citing CrPC section numbers in a BNSS matter, or the reverse, without explaining why.
- Missing a BNSS time limit because the case “started under the old Code”.
- Ignoring the BNS side. A matter with an old offence date but a new FIR may be a BNS-versus-IPC problem before it is a BNSS-versus-CrPC problem.
9. Frequently asked questions
Did the CrPC stop applying altogether on 1 July 2024?
No. It continues to govern matters that were pending on that date, by virtue of Section 531(2)(a) BNSS.
My FIR was registered in June 2024. Which Code applies?
It depends on the stage you are asking about and on how your High Court reads “pending”. The investigation is the clearest CrPC element; later stages are where views diverge.
Does Section 531 affect which penal law applies?
Not directly. Penal law is governed by Section 358 BNS and Article 20(1) of the Constitution. Offences committed before 1 July 2024 are prosecuted under the IPC.
Can I file a bail application under the BNSS for an old FIR?
A fresh bail application filed after 1 July 2024 is generally treated as a BNSS application. Confirm with the practice of the court in which you are appearing.
Do old CrPC judgments still matter?
Yes, very much. Many BNSS provisions reproduce the CrPC provision in substance, and courts routinely rely on CrPC precedents for those. Where the BNSS has made a real change (time limits, custody, electronic processes), the older precedent may not be a safe guide.
10. Checklist before you file
- Dated chronology prepared (FIR, investigation, chargesheet, cognizance, committal, charge)
- Identified which proceeding is being filed and whether any earlier application on the same subject was pending on 1 July 2024
- Read the full text of Section 531 BNSS and Section 358 BNS
- Checked the latest High Court and Supreme Court rulings on the stage in question
- Decided whether to plead CrPC and BNSS in the alternative
- Checked any BNSS time limit that could apply and diarised it
- Mapped every statutory reference to its BNSS or CrPC equivalent in the draft
Section 531 BNSS is short, but it governs the working life of almost every criminal practitioner in India during the transition. The clause preserves the CrPC for what was already pending, and it leaves open how far that protection travels along a case’s life. The safest practice is disciplined: build the timeline, identify the exact proceeding in hand, check current authority for your forum, and plead both frameworks where the position is uncertain.
By entering the email address you agree to our Privacy Policy.
